Eccentric Flower talk:201101/Manga and Cake

From Eccentric Flower

Comments on Eccentric Flower:201101/Manga and Cake

Comment:



Thomas:

Wow, the Cranky Octopus entry made me realize that even is I have read very little of Manga, it is still more than I have read American comics and as result my eyes start moving like they should in manga, NOT the way Cranky Octopus shows they should move.

-- 17:56, 5 January 2011 (GMT)


Settsimaksimin:

that Nausicaa boxed set you have should be in left-to-right. if i remember correctly, Viz did those before Tokyopop changed everyone's expectations. there's a more recent right-to-left version printed at a larger size.

i still don't have much of an opinion on flipped vs. unflipped, but i suppose unflipped means that things get through the production pipeline quicker. it didn't take me very long to get used to right-to-left, but i read a lot of comics.

it may be easier if you 'train' with some stuff done with a less 'creative' layout (closed rectangular panels). Kurosagi Corpse Delivery Service or Emma might meet your tastes... (and it's BD, but maybe Adèle Blanc-Sec?)

anyone interested in manga layout/flow should look at Telophase's Manga Analysis Series, specifically sections 2 through 4: http://telophase.livejournal.com/113219.html

-- 19:01, 5 January 2011 (GMT)


Shmuel:

I have suspected for some time that my experience with Hebrew has made manga a lot easier for me to read. (That is, I don't have any problem knowing what to read first, but I have an awful lot of experience reading things right-to-left.)

-- 20:29, 5 January 2011 (GMT)


Iain:

For some reason, I don't have a particular problem with reading manga right to left. (Though I used to get irked at what was then called OEL Manga -- Original English Language -- for repeating the flow and structure. I think Tokyopop and Viz insisted on it so that they could put it into Japanese more easily. Then both companies killed their OEL lines, so that disappeared anyway.) It just never was that much of a problem for me, for some reason. I do get irritated about the untranslated noises, though; I get that they usually can't do much with those without hurting the artwork, but especially in frames where nothing is going on but background noises, it can be very irritating. One good thing about Kurosagi Corpse Delivery Service is that in the copious editor's notes in the back, they tell you what those sounds are supposed to be.

Another thing you might want to try, if you decide that you'd like to see if simpler art and layout might make it easier for you, would be Ooku by Fumi Yoshinaga; it hypothesizes about what Japan would have looked like if a plague had killed 75% of all males, and continued to do so. (The subject matter is right up your alley, really. That said, I do think that the shogunate's response for itself would be wildly improbable.) There aren't a lot of background noises, and Yoshinaga's art is very delicate but doesn't use terribly complicated layouts.

that's a rant for another day, though.

Like ... tomorrow? Or soon? (What? I want to see you get ranty about comics is all.)

What I really want is The Spirit, the superhero book with the most understated superhero of all time, and the most delicate hand ever for tripping off into the fantastic unexpectedly. But it takes a genius to pull something like that off, and we only get one Will Eisner per generation.

I think you might enjoy the first volume of Darwyn Cooke's reboot of The Spirit. I think he caught most of what made it work without being slavishly devoted to Eisner's style. (On the other hand, if you really really really want something more Eisneresque, you'd probably enjoy the Aragones/Evanier volume, which I utterly hated, because they were basically imitating Eisner.) Alas, nobody has ever managed to solve The Problem of Ebony, though I think Cooke came close. (You'd like the done-in-one black and white backup stories in the current reboot of The Sprit, I think, but it's not probably not worth wading through the front story to do so.)

it may be easier if you 'train' with some stuff done with a less 'creative' layout (closed rectangular panels). Kurosagi Corpse Delivery Service or Emma might meet your tastes... (and it's BD, but maybe Adèle Blanc-Sec?

Bande dessinee isn't normally laid out right to left, though, since French doesn't read that way.

-- 21:04, 5 January 2011 (GMT)


Columbina:

I looked at a couple of those sample pages of Kurosagi Corpse Delivery Service, but I had to stop when I was completely unsure whether the line "Man, it sucks being an entry-level Buddhist" was supposed to be funny. (I thought it was hilarious. Then again, I find the whole idea of a Buddhist university hilarious. Have I mentioned my sense of humor is sort of bizarre?)

-- 21:12, 5 January 2011 (GMT)


Columbina:

That said, I did eventually go read the rest of that excerpt and I gather that the story is supposed to be sort of bizarre too, so maybe I'm okay. (I'd like a footnote on why that forest is such a hotspot for suicides, though.)

-- 21:17, 5 January 2011 (GMT)


Mrissa:

I was there to bring the pumpkin cake. Clearly.

I want to thaw out that loaf of pumpkin bread in the freezer, but I should finish the gingerbread loaf first.

Mmm. Pumpkin.

-- 22:06, 5 January 2011 (GMT)


Iain:

I looked at a couple of those sample pages of Kurosagi Corpse Delivery Service, but I had to stop when I was completely unsure whether the line "Man, it sucks being an entry-level Buddhist" was supposed to be funny.

I always thought it was supposed to be, but it's not hugely important in the scheme of things. Some stories rely on the characters having a knowledge of how Buddhism is supposed to work, for certain aspects, but it doesn't generally assume that the reader knows. And most of the time, it's not at all relevant, except that it's a university. (Also: longest collegiate senior year EVER. Even allowing that the publication schedule here is slower because of translation issues, they've been seniors for about four years now.)

I'd like a footnote on why that forest is such a hotspot for suicides, though.

I think that may actually be covered in the editor's notes. (They're very very ... editorial. And thorough. And opinionated.) The impression I've gotten from the other volumes is that Japan's forests in general are suicide magnets, in part because there are so few of them. People like a nice natural place to shuffle themselves off this mortal coil, it seems.

-- 22:59, 5 January 2011 (GMT)


Settsimaksimin:

Kurosagi Corpse Delivery Service is quite funny! (and also creepy and disgusting--but still funny.) it's one of the rare ones available in the US where the "strange and unusual" isn't dialed up past 11. Kurosagi also has the most amazing and detailed footnotes i've ever seen (puts me in mind of the ones in From Hell). you get a really big chunk of background and explanation of the suicide forest, for example.

sorry, i was trying to shoehorn in Adèle as a general non-manga recommendation of interest, not a right-to-left example.

-- 23:03, 5 January 2011 (GMT)


Ursula:

Have you tried early Love and Rockets, back when they had actual rockets and robots and stuff like that, mixed in with the girly punk soap opera? The Hernandez Brothers are excellent, you're missing out. Early-ish Daniel Clowes could also have a lot to interest you. Check out "Like a Velvet Glove Cast in Iron" sometime.

Does anybody every annotate freakin' manga? There's some baffling cultural thing on nearly every page, and if they'd just have little notes at the bottom of the page that said something like "In Japanese culture, the bubble emerging from his nose means he's in a frenzy of sexual arousal," it would all be easier to follow and it'd be educational to boot!

I like some manga... But a lot of young manga fans remind me of the bicycle racer guy in Breaking Away who desperately wanted to be Italian. Loving manga is fine, but if you read 3000 pages of kinky comics a month and you've never heard of, say, R. Crumb, you're missing out.

-- 23:29, 5 January 2011 (GMT)


Ursula:

Iain: Ebony is a tricky one. When they announced there was going to be a Spirit movie, I remember thinking they should cast Gary Coleman or Emmanuel Lewis or some other adult who could be 12 or 45, and write him as kind of a young Eddie Murphy character, broke and rather frantic but also streetwise and funny.

I think the clumsiest attempt to deal with Ebony was probably Alan Moore's. He told a Spirit story from some jerky guy's POV, and had the guy tell the audience, "I'm afraid I've never been able to see Negroes as anything but stereotypes!" Then he went ahead with an old-fashioned Ebony. Man, was that clunky.

-- 00:02, 6 January 2011 (GMT)


Columbina:

So, I bought volumes one of Kurosagi and Ooku, and I would just like to thank the two of you for the recommendation of the former. I devoured it this evening and I think I am going to have to go buy the next few tomorrow. It's a great mix of Bones with slackers and really dark humor.

I reserve judgement on Ooku. It's certainly interesting so far but I am not sure yet whether I'll want more, whereas with Kurosagi I want more now now now.

I love recommendations I can trust!

-- 00:28, 6 January 2011 (GMT)


Columbina:

P.S. I have had no problem with reading either of those, so I'm wondering now just how much of the trouble is with Monkey Punch's very, um, freeform layouts in Lupin III.

-- 00:30, 6 January 2011 (GMT)


Columbina:

P.P.S. to Ursula: Both of the books I bought today have endnotes and so do many others I've seen. It's a nice thing, I agree, and more should do it.

-- 00:34, 6 January 2011 (GMT)


Ursula:

Endnotes are OK, but they require a lot of flipping back and forth and that can really take you out of a story. I'm talking about little notes at the bottom or sides of the page itself, so you can just absorb that stuff as you go.

-- 01:37, 6 January 2011 (GMT)


Iain:

I'm glad you enjoyed Kurosagi.

I reserve judgement on Ooku. It's certainly interesting so far but I am not sure yet whether I'll want more, whereas with Kurosagi I want more now now now.

It occurs to me that one of the things with Ooku is that it has exactly the issue with Japanese history that I mentioned that Kurosagi doesn't have with its treatment of Buddhism: Ooku assumes a fair amount of knowledge of what was actually supposed to be happening, so that you understand how it's being subverted. If you don't have a decent baseline history of the Tokugawa shogunate, it's probably not as interesting. Plus, while I understand for story purposes why Yoshinaga did what she did with the ooku, I did have a hard time with the concept initially, since I'm pretty sure that the country would have risen in rebellion at the concept that the shogun was keeping hundreds of young men for her own personal use, and there were so few around.

Since you liked Kurosagi, you might also want to try Mail, by Housui Yamazaki, the artist of Kurosagi. I think there were only three volumes published. There's a bit of a crossover with Kurosagi, in which we get the first explanation of what exactly is happening with Karatsu and how his ability really works. It's not necessary to read for Kurosagi; his abilities are explained in more detail in the series.

Depending on how you feel about Astro-Boy, you might also enjoy Pluto: Urasawa x Tezuka, which reworks the story of "The Greatest Robot on Earth" for more modern and adult audiences. The layout is a bit more difficult than Kurosagi, so you'll definitely want to take a look at it first. It doesn't require that you have read the original or watched the television version to understand what's going on.

For what it's worth: MPD Psycho is an indirect prequel for Kurosagi, but you don't have to read it to understand anything, and in fact, I don't recommend reading it at all, unless you have a strong stomach for violence and gore along with the weird. (More violence and gore than Kurosagi, anyway. A detective with multiple personality disorder works with the Metropolitan Police Department of Tokyo to pursue the serial killer that is in turn pursuing him. Said serial killer kidnapped and then mailed the detective's wife to his office in a refrigerator box, missing her clothing, arms and legs, and inducing the aforementioned multiple personality disorder. Which was the point at which I stopped reading.)

-- 06:13, 6 January 2011 (GMT)


Iain:

Iain: Ebony is a tricky one. When they announced there was going to be a Spirit movie, I remember thinking they should cast Gary Coleman or Emmanuel Lewis or some other adult who could be 12 or 45, and write him as kind of a young Eddie Murphy character, broke and rather frantic but also streetwise and funny.

Ursula: the current reboot tried to solve The Problem of Ebony by making the character an adult black female, which could have worked ... except then they made her a damsel in distress in every appearance. And her very first appearance was buck-nekkid, with carefully placed hands, of course. So ... didn't really work well, no. (And then they introduced the character of Imani, an eleven-year-old girl who fills exactly the same role of the streetwise smartass kid that the original Ebony filled, making the reworking of Ebony absolutely pointless.)

-- 06:21, 6 January 2011 (GMT)


Settsimaksimin:

hooray for Kurosagi! i think that the restrained layouts will ease you into the flow better and then you can try the more complicated free-form stuff later. i developed an interest in manga slowly over a long period of time, so i forget how unusual some of the techniques can be. i've gotten my partner interested in some comics but i still haven't found a manga that he was willing to try (my best bet was Kurosagi, and i'm not sure where to go after that). i should really find out what Iain's reading that i'm not, because our tastes sound pretty similar. :)

DO open your Nausicaa set and give it a look. your version should be left-to-right and the layouts are fairly restrained. it's not a perfect thing but, like Eisner, he really knows what he's doing and it's amazing to see.

-- 15:55, 6 January 2011 (GMT)


Settsimaksimin:

(not manga, but a welcome bit of news: POGO VOLUME 1 will be released in the Fall of 2011 - yes, seriously, for real this time; first in a complete reprint series of 12)

-- 16:09, 6 January 2011 (GMT)


ProfRobert:

Again, I don't mean this as a hijacking of this thread, but I thought you'd be amused, as I was, at the twitch of dyslexia I occasionally get. I first read this title as "Magna and Cake," perhaps because I was a Salisbury Cathedral the day before yesterday and saw one of the four remaining original Magna Cartas. So I thought to myself, yeah, Magna Cake-a. If King John had just promised everyone cake, maybe he could have held on to that Divine Right of Kings business a bit longer.

Sorry. Please go back to incomprehensibly discussing Japanese cartoons now.

-- 20:49, 6 January 2011 (GMT)


Columbina:

There's a "cake or death" joke in there somewhere waiting to happen.

Also, I'll have you know we are incomprehensibly discussing Japanese comic books, not Japanese cartoons!

-- 21:04, 6 January 2011 (GMT)


ProfRobert:

Cartoons are what are inside comic books. http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/cartoon From what little I could gather, you are discussing, in part, how to read said cartoons, not some inherent aspect of the books in which they appear. But it's incomprehensible, so I could be wrong here.

-- 21:53, 6 January 2011 (GMT)


Spc476:

Cerebus (no longer running, but you can still get the "phone books") might fit your bill. It started off as a parody of Conan the Barbarian/Howard the Duck (Cerebus is an aardvark barbarian in a human world), then turned into social satire (in High Society where Cerebus was running for Prime Minister of a city-state against a goat, then into Church and State I and II, where Cerebus was made Pope). Past that, it turns into mainstream litfic (with an aardvark) where nothing much happens (but the artwork is absolutely fantastic). Just don't look too closely to the politics of the artist, Dave Sim (he want, as they say, batshit crazy).

Another underrated American comic book is Uncle Scrooge (no, really!). In the hands of Carl Banks (and even as an 8 year old, I could tell a Carl Banks story from every other one, even if Disney never allowed the artists to sign their name) Uncle Scrooge was a wonderful read (and I certainly learned a ton---where else would you learn of a credible reason for the Flying Dutchman? Or one could use inner tubes to raise a sunk Mississippian paddle boat?). Don Rosa's Uncle Scrooge is also worth reading (he did an Inception style story years before the movie came out, and it was logically consistent).

And that's pretty much it for the comic books I've read (oh, I've read a ton of them, but the only two that have ever stood out were Cerebus and Uncle Scrooge).

-- 23:33, 6 January 2011 (GMT)


Columbina:

Oh, we have all the Cerebus books. They belong to my wife. I think she bought the last few out of some sense of completion. I made it all the way through the story up to the end of Church and State. About then I realized that the book had mutated into something I was uninterested in (mostly because Dave Sim had gone batshit insane), and I stopped. I have no idea how my wife persevered, especially in the face of Sim's extreme misogyny.

I hate to correct you, because I don't want to sound like I'm diminishing, but (he whispers hesitantly) it's Carl Barks.

You're not the only former 8-year-old who has expressed that sentiment - he was legendarily known as, in the era of unsigned art, as "the good duck guy." I didn't discover Barks' stories until later - with one or two exceptions which I barely remember from childhood - and I have a lot of catching up to do, which is why I am excited about this announcement which has had some of the circles I run in all abuzz.

-- 01:13, 7 January 2011 (GMT)


Spc476:

Mea culpa! You're right. Sigh. And I even *have* a book of collected Uncle Scrooge comics by Carl Barks right on my book shelf.

Sigh.

But that announcement ... wow! I just wish it was more than two volumes per year.


-- 09:32, 7 January 2011 (GMT)


Spc476:

And now for mixing two topics in one!

Inception, Uncle Scrooge style (drawn by Don Rosa I belive), before the movie came out: http://disneycomics.free.fr/Ducks/Rosa/show.php?num=1&loc=D2002-033&s=date


-- 04:05, 8 January 2011 (GMT)


Ysabel:

I hesitate to make this comment, but you also complain when I don't comment.  :)

I wish I had something useful to tell you. I love manga and I read a lot of it and you're not the first person I know to have trouble with the directionality assumptions. Manga just works for me, better than western comics, for whatever reason (though I have trained myself to read western comics too). Flipped manga actually tends to get me lost very easily, for whatever reason. I hate flipped manga for this reason -- it appears to do to me exactly what you describe manga doing to you normally.

-- 16:55, 10 January 2011 (GMT)

Personal tools
eccentric flower
fiction